Writers' Community!
Your are not logged in - Log in / Sign up

Featured Columnists Advice Columnists
Halls of Fame Q&A Contests Recent Things Polls NEW!
Article Submission
We Need YOUR Articles!
We'll Promote Them for FREE!

Author Login

New Authors
Join Us!


Now Serving 7,133 Authors
80,157 Quality Articles
& 7,870 Current Users Online!
Featured Authors
Joel Hirschhorn (2,924)
Leah Gray - Illustrator (13,994)
Linda DeWitt (2,030)
E. Raymond Rock (3,218)
Ronyae (3,957)
Joel Hendon (30,406)
Chris Cole (708)
Bob Alexander (2,014)
Dianne Lehmann (5,827)
Terry Mitchell (5,169)
Ella Camp (386)
Gerry Charbonneau (1,404)
Ira Coffin (74,360)
Connor Davidson (8,139)

View All Featured Authors
Most Recent
How to Meditate Using a Zen Meditation Technique

Delilah’s Den: Mind-Blowing Heart-Stopping Sexual Unions

Blessed Tree!

Bartolo Longo - from Satanist to Saint

Miracles in the life of Saint John Vianney

Live and die like Solomon!

Thoughtless People

Nine!

The Most Famous Bible Verse

Jesus speaks to Saint Thomas Aquinas

Home » Categories » Society » Religion and Spirituality » Thoughts on the Christian Marketplace » Printer Friendly

Jared Wilson Jared Wilson (1,108)
Jared Wilson

Thoughts on the Christian Marketplace

Rated 4 out of 5
No Reader Ratings Available ?
Submitted Thursday, September 04, 2008
Rate It  /  View Comments  /  View All Articles submitted by Jared Wilson
http://www.elementnashville.org
Log in to become a member of Jared Wilson's Fan Club!

I have previously offered a broad semi-defense of the Christian subcultural marketplace. Now I'd like to offer some more targeted thoughts expanding and elaborating on the general ideas expressed there.

But let's first establish what exactly constitutes "the Christian market." Most discussions seem to focus on the goods and services provided by publishers, artists, and assorted salespersons, but more directly speaking, the Christian market is really Christian consumers . And this is why the Christian marketplace is not so easily dismantled. It exists because there are people -- a sizable number of them, actually -- who want to buy goods and services that are in some way qualified as "Christian." With this in mind, then, it is not the maker of Testamints that is the problem (assuming you think there is a problem) but rather the person who prefers to buy mints with Bible verses on them.

I have long held that the problem of the Christian marketplace is a pulpit problem. By this I mean that if we want to be serious about encouraging greater discernment and quality in the Christian's consumption of art (and further, if we want to gradually squelch the Christian's ravenous consumerism), we have to begin nurturing this difference on the pastoral and ecclesiological levels.

But I still think the problem is often overstated. Like most everyone, I share the disdain for what Christian music pioneer Keith Green called "Jesus junk," those little toys and trinkets -- which these days range from disposable things like "Jesus fish" car emblems to nice things like Fruit of the Spirit dessert plates (both of which I have owned) -- that overpopulate the bins and shelves of your local Christian retailer. But unlike many people in my position -- those who regularly voice criticism of the Christian culture and the evangelical Church -- I do not believe the situation is all that dire. Or all that important.

One thing I relish pointing out is the latent hypocrisy in some of the critics' calls to dismantle the Christian market. One of the most influential treatises encouraging Christian artists to abandon the "Christian ghetto" and take their works to the mainstream was Roaring Lambs by the late Bob Briner. Roaring Lambs was published by Zondervan, a Christian publisher, and was sold predominantly in Christian bookstores. Its primary readership was the Christian market, of course, and this book actually had its own tie-in Contemporary Christian Music album full of songs "inspired" by it, each of which was performed by artists from the CCM scene. Only Sixpence None the Richer (or perhaps Jars of Clay) could actually qualify as having some mainstream cred.

This is nearly always the case. Any book or article written about dismantling the Christian marketplace immediately must embrace the irony of being written for the Christian marketplace and for Christian readers. One pastor-blogger I read recently rejoiced greatly at the very idea that the Christian book market may be going south, which is odd given that every single one of his books was written for Christians and was printed by a Christian publisher. This particular pastor's angle is that if Christians must compete in the mainstream, the quality of their material will increase. He doesn't know this (I don't think), but he will not like the results if he gets his wish, because he is a rather poor writer and his books have only seen print because of his supposed name recognition in Christian circles.

Likewise, another blogger whose bread and butter is the routine trashing of the Christian retail scene is a former editor of CCM Magazine and a published author whose books (every last one of them) are published by Christian publishers. If the Christian retail scene didn't exist, he'd be out of work.

As I argued in my earlier piece, the dismantling of the Christian market will not be a good thing. It's not even a realistic thing. There are legitimate appetites for "Christian products" like church resources, Bibles and Bible studies, theological texts, and other works on spirituality. Mainstream publishers have no interest in publishing these works unless there is proven marketability, and of course such marketability only comes from Christian readership. Do we really want non-Christian companies and their non-Christian editors dictating and guiding the content of Bible studies and systematic theologies? (And, yes, I realize that most of the major Christian publishers are already owned by bigger publishing conglomerates.)

I also argued before that asking Christian artists to start creating less "Christian" art can end up being just as marginalizing and ghetto-izing as creating for the Christian market is assumed to be. What if an artist wants to sing freely about Jesus and their salvation? You may think this doesn't make for good art, but creating objective categories for subjective determinations is exactly the sort of restriction the encouragements toward creative freedom mean to avoid. The truth is that the mainstream market has no room for artists with lots of Jesus in their music. By telling our artists to ditch the Jesus talk, aren't we somehow making an idol of artistic credibility?

Another criticism one often hears about the Christian market is its lack of quality.

My response is a cynical "Compared to what?"

I wonder if those complaining about the superficiality of Christian pop music have listened to mainstream pop music any time lately. It sucks. Big time.

By contrast, the stuff on your typical Christian Top 40 station is well made, well sung, well produced, well created. It may not be my cup of tea stylistically , and I may wish my local Christian radio station played more than six songs on rotation, but style and the shallow playlist of the radio station are not the same as musical quality. The truth is that the vast majority of Christian musical artists are talented musicians and vocalists, and the larger truth is, they are just as talented as their secular counterparts, with the added bonus that they are usually singing about much more edifying things.


The real issue, then, is not quality, really, but the breadth of offerings in the marketplace. My main complaint has never been that the stuff on Christian radio or on Christian bookshelves is not good. It's only that there doesn't seem to be a viable place in the Christian market for non-pop offerings. To explain: You can walk into a Borders or Barnes and Noble bookseller and buy either Danielle Steele or John Updike. You can buy Stephen King or you can buy Fyodor Dostoyevsky.

Not so in the Christian bookstore. The Christian literary offerings, especially in the category of fiction/novels, are almost exclusively of the "genre fiction" variety, the Christian variations of Danielle Steele and Stephen King (and John Grisham, Tom Clancy, etc). There is essentially no such thing as Christian literary fiction.

This is not the problem of the Christian marketplace. The market sells based on demonstrative needs. As I said before, I don't think the problem of the existence of the Christian marketplace is all that dire or even all that important.

The real problem -- the one both dire and important -- is that Christian consumerism is basically as deep as the shallowest end of mainstream consumerism. And that is not the fault of Testamints or "God's Gym" T-shirts or WWJD bracelets, let alone Mercy Me or Michael W. Smith. It is the fault of a gospel-deficient Church and a discipleship culture that has been trained to be both in and of the world.


Jared Wilson is the pastor and co-founder of Element, a missional Christian community in Nashville, Tennessee, and an award-winning writer whose articles, essays, and short stories have appeared in numerous publications.


Jared's first book, The Unvarnished Jesus, releases Fall 2009 from Kregel.

 

A graduate of Middle Tennessee State University, he lives outside Nashville with his wife and two daughters.

Encounter Jared's passion for the ongoing reformation of the evangelical church almost daily at www.gospeldrivenchurch.com.






Reprint Rights

Log in to become a member of Jared Wilson's Fan Club!
Comments on this article: (1 total)


» left by Jane Bullard (1 year 150 days ago.)
Reader Rating: 4 out of 5
Hi, Jared. I enjoyed this article. My husband and I are Christians who publish books written by Christian writers. Many like me and my husband have reasons for getting into this area, which we never expected to do. It is a risky business full of temptations ethical and otherwise. Books by Christian authors used to be published by mainstream publishers like Doubleday and others. Those were better days in many ways.
 

Respond to this comment

Was this article helpful to you? Leave a Public Comment or Question:

This Article has been viewed 342 times.
Article added to SearchWarp.com on 9/4/2008 4:30:10 PM.
View other articles written by Jared Wilson (1,108)
Jared Wilson


If you found this article interesting, you may want to check out:

Disclaimer:  All information on this site is provided for informational purposes only! By no means is any information presented herein intended to substitute for the advice provided to you by any health care or other professional or organization.


Today's Most Popular
Matching of Horoscopes For Marriage

What is the Most Important Thing in a Romantic Relationship?

Thoughtless People

10 Ways to Boost Your Psychic Abilities

Origin of 'See no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil'

How to survive 2012

Telepathic Communication Between Two People

Before You Bash Judas: How Much is 30 Pieces of Silver?

Is it Right to Judge Others?

Gratitude - Top Ten Reasons to Adopt the LAW of GRATITUDE

Viewed from Cache. Load Time: 0.016.

Home  |  Page Two  |  FAQ's  |  Contact  |  Terms of Service  |  Article Submission Guidelines  |  Questions & Answers  |  Privacy  |  Mission / About
Copyright © 1999-2010 SearchWarp.com, All Rights Reserved - SearchWarp.com is an IcoLogic, Inc. Company