Every teacher, every counselor knows youngsters who won't do their work. Some of these work refusers often fail to show up. When they do show up, they often say little, and some may be nearly mute. Some may not even make eye contact.
Typically, adults consider two options: pushing the child or backing off.
All types of "pushing" can fail, whether rewards, consequences, pressure or logic are used. Backing off can't ever work because if you back off then you're not offering the child an education, or whatever your service is. The world demands skills from every one of us. No exceptions are made for those who endured abuse or neglect. We spend hours thoroughly covering work refusers in our workshop, and can't fit all that comprehensive, step-by-step guidance here, but we'll give you some key tips on one central, critical aspect of working with work refusers: control.
It's Pain, Not a Game Many work refusers face enormous challenges from severe family problems like violence or incest, to challenges like disabilities and emotional disorders. Work refusal can appear to be a game, but especially with victimized youngsters, it's not a game at all. Getting "stuck" is the only way they know to survive.
Strategy: Few kids will ever say "I was beaten last night so math seems irrelevant. Can I skip the exam?" For distressed kids who don't wish to disclose the nature of their distress, simply allow them to say whether it's a "good work day" or "bad work day." How much work could you do after a beating? Deeply appreciative of accommodations, some students work very hard on the days that they're able to.
You're a Life Line You may be the only sane, sober adult some students know-- a fact that you may want to keep in mind.
Strategy: If you're a teacher, then you may live with on-going "testing mania," and other big pressures to produce results at school. It can be hard to remember that humanity is always more important than scores. Forget the humanity you won't get good scores. Remember the humanity, you'll maximize your humans and their scores.
Tiny Increments Traumatized kids have so little energy left for school: Surviving the beatings, homelessness, incest, or neglect can demand all the child's resources.
Strategy: Raise expectations in tiny increments. If a student says your goals are too easy, that's just right. Aim for lots of small successes rather than a big failure followed by seizing up and absences.
Discern Causes Look beyond the work refusal to improve it.
Strategy: Ask students why they don't work. When many say "I don't know," reply: "If you did know, what would it be?" This off- beat method can yield important answers. Be ready to arrange help for the serious issues students cite.
Strike the Balance Neither pushing or backing off works, even though they tend to be the most commonly used options.
Strategy: So what does work if the two most common methods are so ineffective? Striking the balance between those two options. That means that you never abandon your mission, but you don't accomplish it at all costs. That balance is dynamic and shifting, so it will vary from day to day, even hour to hour. For example, imagine a child has a dad who is a long haul truck driver, and very violent. When dad is home, this is a very troubled kid who does little work: coping with the violence takes all her energy. So, you increase the accommodations you make, and decrease expectations. When dad is on the road, the child may be more functional. Now, you reduce the accommodations, and increase expectations. If you correctly strike the balance, you'll maximize the education and other services that you can give to children carrying unbearable loads.
A Final Thought: Consider this true story as a way to understand your potential impact on vulnerable children who refuse to work: "Mom hasn't moved in three days. I'm worried," the first grader said when asked why he couldn't work. Tragically, upon investigation, the boy's Mom had passed without any adult knowing. Looking back, would you want to have taken the time to ask, or would you be satisfied that you had only focused on getting the work done?
LIKE THESE STRATEGIES?
More dynamic, powerful strategies are in our newest book, "Maximum-Strength Motivation-Makers." It's just $13, and designed to give you all the tools you need to motivate unmotivated students. Learn more about it at:
http://www.youthchg.com. Order by phone: 1-800-545-5736.
Ruth Herman Wells MS is the director of Youth Change. Get hundreds more resources at http://www.youthchg.com. You will find countless resources including many more innovative, problem-stopping interventions (just click the link above). For classroom management tools, visit http://www.theclassroommanagementsite.com. Ruth is the author of dozens of books including the popular Temper and Tantrum Tamers, Turn On the Turned-Off Student, Last Chance School Success Guide and Maximum-Strength Motivation-Makers. She annually trains hundreds of teachers, counselors and youth professionals in staff development workshops, conferences, seminars and inservice throughout the country. With Ruth's solutions, working with difficult students doesn't have to be so difficult.
» left by Wm. M. Carr from Wifnfield Mo (2 years 265 days ago.)
this is all good but what do you do if you try all this and the students still refuse Respond to this comment
I didn't find any tangible strategies in this article. While it is true that students often carry intense baggage with them to school, it is also very common that they just don't want to work. What do you do when it is the latter?
The was no help at all. Most of us know there are several at0home issues that influence a student's behavior in the classroom. The problem with teachers is.. What do we do in the classroom??
» left by E. Jones from Cleveland OH (79 days 1 hour ago.)
This article is good if the issue happens to be caused by such challenges but often the case is that there is no such challenge. Perhaps it would be useful to explore the different reasons a student would refuse to do school work.
» left by Anonymous (2 hours 11 minutes ago.) New Comment!
What to do when the student's home life is just fine? Sometimes kids are just babied so much they think they don't have to do any work. Then what do teachers do?
Was this article helpful to you? Leave a Public Comment or Question:
This Article has been viewed 2,542 times.
Article added to SearchWarp.com on 4/4/2006 1:23:39 PM. View other articles written byRuth Herman Wells(2,759)
If you found this article interesting, you may want to check out:
Disclaimer: All information on this site is provided for informational purposes only! By no means is any
information presented herein intended to substitute for the advice provided to you by any health care or other professional
or organization.
tweet this!
